The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures by law enforcement. Police cannot search your home, vehicle, or person without a valid warrant, probable cause, or specific legal exceptions. However, violations of Fourth Amendment rights occur frequently, leading to illegally obtained evidence that can be used against defendants in court.
If you have been arrested or charged with a crime in New York, it is crucial to understand how the Fourth Amendment applies to your case and how to fight illegal searches and seizures to protect your rights and freedom. Here, our Binghamton criminal defense attorneys explain.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7b1cd/7b1cd838d6cab8d13f22d916421caa72c815be64" alt="Fourth Amendment Rights"
When Are Searches and Seizures Considered Illegal?
A search or seizure is considered illegal if law enforcement violates your constitutional protections by:
- Searching without a warrant – In most cases, police need a valid warrant issued by a judge before searching your property.
- Lacking probable cause – If police do not have reasonable suspicion or evidence that a crime has occurred, a search is unlawful.
- Extending a traffic stop without justification – Officers cannot prolong a stop to conduct an unwarranted search unless they have specific legal grounds.
- Performing an illegal stop-and-frisk – Police must have reasonable suspicion to conduct a pat-down; they cannot stop someone without justification.
- Searching outside the scope of a warrant – If police search areas not listed on the warrant or seize items not specified, they violate the Fourth Amendment.
How to Challenge an Illegal Search and Seizure in Binghamton, New York
If law enforcement violated your Fourth Amendment rights, any evidence obtained during the illegal search may be thrown out of court.
Here’s how a skilled New York criminal defense attorney can fight back:
- Filing a Motion to Suppress Evidence
One of the most effective ways to challenge an illegal search is through a motion to suppress evidence. This motion excludes any unlawfully obtained evidence if granted, making it inadmissible in court. Without key evidence, the prosecution may have to drop or reduce charges.
- Proving a Lack of Probable Cause
If police searched your property without a warrant or valid reason, your attorney could argue that they lacked probable cause, making the search unconstitutional.
- Challenging a Warrant’s Validity
Not all search warrants are legally valid. If the warrant was obtained based on false information, lacked proper details, or was overly broad, your defense lawyer may challenge its legality in court.
- Establishing That Your Consent Was Coerced
Police officers sometimes claim that a suspect “consented” to a search. However, the search may still be illegal if your consent was forced, pressured, or given under pretenses.
Why You Need an Experienced Criminal Defense Attorney in Binghamton, New York
Fourth Amendment violations are complex legal issues that require an aggressive defense strategy. At O’Brien & Eggleston, we thoroughly analyze police conduct, challenge unlawful searches, and fight to protect your constitutional rights.
Contact Our Albany Criminal Defense Lawyers at O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC Today
If you believe you were the victim of an illegal search or seizure in Binghamton, don’t wait to take action. Contact our Broome County criminal defense attorneys at O’Brien & Eggleston at (518)-391-2369 or online for a free consultation. Let us fight to suppress unlawfully obtained evidence and protect your freedom.